Jury awards brothers $700K in Green Bay diocese lawsuit

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.
Green Bay Diocese

Green Bay Diocese

APPLETON (AP) — An Outagamie County jury on Monday awarded two brothers $700,000 in a fraud trial against the Catholic Diocese of Green Bay.

The civil jury found the diocese responsible Monday, May 21st for concealing a former priest’s history of child molestation. Brothers Todd and Troy Merryfield sued the diocese in 2008, alleging the diocese was aware that Rev. John Feeney sexually assaulted others before 1978, when it assigned him to Freedom’s St. Nicholas Church. Feeney was convicted in 2004 for the sexual assaults of the Merryfields and has already served his prison sentence.

The jury awarded Troy Merryfield $475,000 and Todd $225,000 in damages. The Merryfields’ attorneys had asked the jury to award Troy $1.8 million in damages and Todd $900,000. The diocese attorney, Patrick Brennan, said if the jury found the diocese liable, the brothers should be given $100,000.

In a statement Monday, the diocese said it regrets what happened to the Merryfields and apologized “for the pain and suffering it has caused them and their families.” But the diocese said it disagrees with the jury’s verdict and “will have to assess our legal remedies of appeal to ensure that truth and justice prevail.”

The diocese has said it had no knowledge of abuse. The jury will return for a second phase of the trial Wednesday, May 23rd to consider possible punitive damages against the diocese and will hear more witnesses.

The diocese argued the psychological impact of the abuse on the brothers was minor and there’s not enough evidence to back the Merryfields’ claim that Bishop Aloysius Wyciso, who was in charge of ensuring priests were fit to serve, knew Feeney had a history of
molestation and committed fraud by representing him as safe.

Over the past week, Jeffrey Anderson and John Peterson, the Merryfields’ attorneys, called several priests as witnesses. The priests testified there were allegations of inappropriate behavior by Feeney — that he swam naked with boys and showered with them after basketball games — long before he assaulted the Merryfields in 1978.

But the bishop, who died in 2005, said in a previous deposition testimony that if there was merit to complaints of sexual abuse by Feeney, he would have immediately suspended the priest. Feeney has been defrocked and was recently released from prison.

Related stories: