Attorney: Girl accused in Slenderman stabbing belongs in juvenile court

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

WAUKESHA COUNTY (WITI/AP) — An attorney for one of two girls accused of repeatedly stabbing a classmate to please the fictional character Slenderman says he will prove his client does not belong in adult court.

A preliminary hearing for the two girls got underway Monday, February 16th in a packed courtroom in Waukesha County. Prosecutors charged 12-year-old Morgan Geyser and 12-year-old Anissa Weier as adults with first-degree attempted homicide in the attack at a Waukesha park last May.

Defense attorney Anthony Cotton said during his opening statement that his client's obsession with Slenderman warrants a lesser charge of second-degree attempted homicide that could be dealt with in juvenile court.

In court, for the first time on Monday, drawings from a notebook found in Geyser's locker after the stabbing were shown, and details about the plan that was reportedly five months in the making were brought to light. Also -- video of the girls accused in this case talking about why they did it.

This, as Geyser's attorney says he wants the case moved into juvenile court because of Geyser's deep belief in the evil fictional character Slenderman.

"She made the deal previously with Slenderman that if they didn't follow through, their families would be in danger," Waukesha Police Detective Michelle Trussoni said.

"Morgan got on top of (the victim's) legs. She sat on her legs. She got real close to (the victim) and whispered in her ear 'I'm so sorry,' and then started stabbing her," Shelly Fischer with the Waukesha Police Department said.

Shown in court Monday were excerpts from Geyser's notebook -- including a supply list for the alleged crime, sketches of Slenderman and sayings like "help never comes."

In a video interview, Weier told a detective she did it because she wanted to prove Slenderman was real, and because she was afraid of him.

"Well yeah. He is anywhere from 14 to 60 feet tall. He constantly wears a suit. He doesn`t have a face. He targets children. He has tendrils on his back. I was really scared he could kill my whole family in three seconds," Weier said in the video.

A detective interviewed Geyser and reported she had no remorse -- that it was easier not to feel anything.

The girls' preliminary hearing continues Tuesday -- and it's expected we'll learn whether this case will go to trial. If it does, a later court date will determine whether that will happen in adult or juvenile court.

The victim was stabbed 19 times, but managed to crawl to a nearby path where a bicyclist found her.

Related links:


  • guest73

    Easy to tell whose parents have Money. One goes back to Winnebago, for “treatment,” because she’s “ill.” The other goes back to West Bend, to be “detained,” because she’s a criminal. You get the best defense you can afford.

  • NO Trolley

    These 2 girls KNEW what they were doing. PLANNED for months to stab their classmate to death (Thankfully the girl lived.) They both deserve to be tried as adults and left in prison with NO parole.

  • exlonghauler

    Seems like so many kids now day have no sense of consequence for their actions. Lack of discipline and corrective action in their raising may have had something to do with this nightmare.

  • tell the truth

    Both are “”adult””guilty.planned this for FIVE. MONTHS..REALLY. .NEEDS TO BE LOCKED UP for as long as possible..if not forever..dont let them “almost kill” someone else…

  • Mike Johnson

    premeditated attempted murder and this attorney thinks they should be charged as kids? that would get them locked up until age 25 max and all records are sealed so they wouldnt even have the felon label to ruin their lives. the attorney who defends this trash is almost as guilty as they are for even trying to get them out of what they have done

  • lisa

    I feel this is BS to the Max. They should sit for what they did to that poor girl. and NEVER see the LIGHT of DAY AGAIN

  • braken da law

    Lock em both up and loose the key, if they get out at the age of 25 they will be a wreck and we’ll end up paying for both of em anyway, my daughter went to school with these two freaks and thats what they are , parents are no better!!!

  • Melissa

    I cannot imagine what it would be like to be the parent of a child who committed such a horrendous, malicious and terrifying crime such as this. But, you have to be an IDIOT to believe that her crimes should be overlooked because she is unstable. She was stable and sane enough to meticulously plan and re-plan the crime, to plan out supplies needed, to plan on times and change plans, and then plan on a story. Sorry, but mental illness does not in any way excuse the crime. Period.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.