“Saved by the Bell” actor Dustin Diamond gets 120 days in jail for bar stabbing

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

PORT WASHINGTON — Dustin Diamond, the actor who portrayed Screech on the 1990s TV show “Saved by the Bell,” was sentenced to 120 days in jail (with Huber work release privileges) on Thursday, June 25th for a stabbing that occurred in a Port Washington bar on Christmas night.

"I think that coming out with that knife has to send a message to the community that we're just not gonna live like this," said Ozaukee County Judge Paul Malloy.

An Ozaukee County jury found Diamond guilty Friday, May 29th of two misdemeanor charges: disorderly conduct and disorderly conduct while armed. But it found him not guilty of one felony charge.

Diamond and his fiancee, Amanda Schutz, were involved in an altercation inside the Grand Avenue Saloon in Port Washington, during which another man suffered a stab wound. Schutz received a $500 fine for her involvement in the incident. She was found guilty of one misdemeanor count of disorderly conduct.

Dustin Diamond and Amanda Schutz

Dustin Diamond and Amanda Schutz

The attorneys representing Diamond and Schutz say their clients are surprised by Diamond's sentence.

"I think we were hoping for something more lenient," said attorney Thomas Alberti. "Dustin understands that it's -- it needs to send a message to the community that you just need to calm down, diffuse things. He realizes what he did escalated things, so it had to happen I think."

During the hearing, Diamond spoke in court.

"Let me express just how sorry I am that a night that centers around celebrating peace and love could turn into a night of immense regret, for the rest of one's life, "said Diamond. "Even though my intentions were solely to defend a loved one, they nevertheless were the cause of the single most terrifying experience of my entire life. A night in the emergency room would be infinitely better than facing a future of being seen as a criminal."

Dustin Diamond took the stand in his own defense Friday, May 29th. While on the stand, Diamond described in detail what happened on that Christmas Day at the Grand Avenue Saloon. He told the court and jury everything was prompted by someone being aggressive with Amanda Schutz, who was with him at the bar.

Grand Avenue Saloon Port Washington

Grand Avenue Saloon Port Washington

Diamond testified he heard Schutz scream — and when he looked back at her, he noticed there was blood coming from her face, as if someone had hit her. He indicated he was scared — and felt the atmosphere in the bar was “aggressive and unstable.”

“They started taking note who we were, who I was. They started taking pictures and laughing and making it a game to bump into us and trying to capture it on video or camera,” Diamond said.

But he says he didn’t pull out the knife until he saw his fiancée, Amanda, whom he often refers to as his ‘wife,’ get injured.

He told the court he didn’t realize anyone was injured by the knife.

“I did not swing or motion the knife at him at all. I think he injured himself when he grabbed at me,” said Diamond.

The fact he was unaware of the injury was reiterated when an interview he had with police from that night was played in court.

But what the DA says is unclear, is why Diamond’s story the night he was taken into custody, differs in many ways from the way he tells it in court.

“You’re basically saying in version two that Amanda went into the crowd to confront the people that were antagonizing her correct?” the DA asked.

Eventually, Diamond said he and Schutz made it out of the bar — and left the scene prior to police showing up. Diamond testified the two of them were later interviewed by police — and he admitted lying about having a pocketknife. He said he did that because he thought the situation at the bar was over and done with.

CLICK HERE to take a look at Dustin Diamond’s career history, dating back to 1987.


    • Mark

      Agreed. This seems a little ridiculous… I’m very surprised he got any jail time at all. Figured if anything they’d throw 50 hours of community service at him. Maybe the judge wants his 15 minutes..

    • selfentitled

      I wonder if this is a Ozaukee County -vs- Milwaukee County difference. Seems pretty harsh considering the situation.

    • JMP

      His story was inconsistent. He admitted to lying to the police. And the fact the girlfriend was found guilty of disorderly conduct seem to suggest the girlfriend’s actions may have started the fight…In which a guy gets stabbed and the perpetrator(s) flee the scene…Don’t flee the scene, lie to the police about not having a weapon, lie in court and expect leniency. Crazy.

  • Brisls

    Our naughty boy does armed robbery, holds a woman hostage in her car for keys, rob her, then gets probation here in Milwaukee. He then goes on to shoot a Wauwatosa detective. Diamond was being harassed, his girlfriend was punched in the face, they tried to leave and were confronted even more. He goes to jail???? Was the guy who got cut charged with anything? If he/.they had any class, he/they would have left Diamond alone to enjoy his evening.

  • #FreeDustin!

    Do you know know how to read? From the story: “…sentenced to 120 days in jail (with Huber work release privileges).”

Comments are closed.