Case closed: Judge sentences James Gill to nine years in prison for armed robberies

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

James Gill

MILWAUKEE — A Milwaukee County judge sentenced 21-year-old James Gill on Monday, July 27th to nine years in prison and another seven years of extended supervision. This, after he pleaded guilty in February to two counts of armed robbery as party to a crime. Two additional counts were dismissed.

Gill was charged in connection with four separate armed robberies that occurred in May 2014. A second individual charged in this case — 25-year-old Norman Smith III pleaded guilty to two counts of armed robbery as party to a crime. Smith was sentenced in March — also to nine years in prison.

According to a criminal complaint filed against them, Gill and Smith were involved in one armed robbery on May 25th and three armed robberies on May 28th in 2014.

On May 25th, police say Gill and Smith approached two women near W. Hampton Avenue and N. 49th Street with a handgun and demanded property.The men obtained purses and  phones from the women before fleeing the scene on foot.

Through a photo array, both victims were able to identify Gill as the man with the gun that demanded property. Through another photo array, one of the victims was able to identify Smith as the second suspect that demanded property.

The second armed robbery occurred on May 28th in the parking lot of a Walmart in the Village of West Milwaukee.

Police say Gill and Smith approached a woman as she was exiting her vehicle and demanded property. Gill, who was the passenger in the vehicle Smith was driving, allegedly approached the victim, pointed a gun at her stomach and stated, “Where’s your money? Where’s your purse? Give me everything you have.”

The victim gave Gill her cell phone and then begged him to let her get her baby out of the car, police say.

Following the robbery, Gill ran back to the vehicle and both suspects fled the scene.

The third armed robbery also took place in the parking lot of a Walmart. This time, police say Gill and Smith approached a woman exiting her vehicle at the Walmart on 27th Street in Franklin, saying “Don’t do anything. Get in the car. Don’t say anything.”

The victim told police that she pushed her purse at Gill and then began to walk toward a security officer. Once the victim reached the security vehicle she saw Gill get into her vehicle and drive away.

Gill eventually abandoned the victim’s SUV and took approximately $50, according to police.

The suspects are also accused of robbing a woman who was walking in an alley near Burleigh and Holton. Police say Gill and Smith spotted the woman walking in the rear alley to her residence with a “long case” and decided to rob her.

Court documents show Gill approached the woman and said, “give me all your stuff” and pointed a silver semi-automatic handgun at her knees.Gill then grabbed the victim’s custom longbow, which was in a carrying case. At that time, the victim began to beg Gill not to take her belongings. While begging Gill, the victim observed the driver of the vehicle, later identified as Smith, tell Gill to “just shoot her and take it.”

Gill then grabbed the bow and pushed the victim to the ground, according to police. Gill told authorities that after he took the case, he got back into the car and they drove to a gas station.



  • Fred

    From reading the story, those two thugs were responsible for a wave of terror. Too bad they only got nine years for all that mayhem, but it’s better than no prison time.

  • mr wrestling

    Life of a criminal 101. Dont have any face tattoos. Just by the looks of him he was probably too stupid to realize he had them and no one would recognize him.

    • MilTownHomie

      Agreed Dighard. That’s not a punishment, it’s a vacation on the taxpayers expense. He will be out to terrorize in his 30s or otherwise known as “in the prime of his life”

  • jim (a different jim)

    If your going to be a criminal, a “lucky” horseshoe between your eyes is a fairly certain way to make sure your luck runs out. Eh, shouldn’t be a shock though, if this person was smart, he would be a productive member of society so I shouldn’t have any shock that he did something dumb.

  • Wischneider

    So, anyone else think that his tattoo on his forehead reminds you of Teal’c in the TV show “Stargate SG-1?”

  • Anastasia McAdoo

    He is a young man who made a mistake most of what was reported was not true locking him away won’t help he needs help

  • Taxpayer lives matter

    Ah those liberals saving cats and dogs from the street only to take them home and get their face ripped off. Time to execute these scumbags by firing squad at red arrow park in honor of our veterans.

  • dick

    These poor scum of the earth brothers should be locked away for 20-30 years! They robbed there own kind with no reason not because they were broke or had a baby at home but for there own petty satisfaction and enjoyment! They don’t need help they know how to make right and wrong decisions they need consequences and responsibility! They will get that in the jail to bad it will waste away there years and opportunities to do something better then rob someone for $50 and then think that the next person “walking with a big case” was a good target! HA! Did they think it was filled with money! Im sure once they figured out it was a musical instrument it was as useless as a textbook in school! The judge should be fired!

  • YO

    He looks like a animal. He should be shot immediately and hang a black lives matter bib over his neck as he accepts multiple bullets in his exploding chest unleashed from 20 high powered rifles. That should teach him a lesson.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.