“The state is going to appeal:” Right-to-work supporters say victory for unions will be short-lived

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.
Data pix.

MILWAUKEE -- Right-to-work is struck down as Wisconsin law, but for how long? Supporters of the law say it's just a matter of time until a higher court reverses Friday's ruling. Labor leaders say regardless of what happens, that decision is a major victory.Walker

Monday, April 11th Governor Scott Walker brushed off the idea his administration suffered a setback.

"Ultimately, it's been upheld elsewhere in the country, we believe it'll be upheld here," said Walker.

Critics of right-to-work, the Wisconsin Labor Law, struck down Friday by a Dane County judge, say that's exactly what happened.judge

"It's a check mark on the Walker administration as to what they're actually doing," said Dan Bukiewicz, Milwaukee Building and Construction Trades Council.

Right-to-work bans union shops from charging mandatory fees to non-members. Opponents crowded the Capitol last March. They argue right-to-work encourages free-loading since federal law regarding the "right to fair representation" requires unions to represent non-members too.


"You could look at it as property taxes. I pay property taxes. Can I opt out and still choose to get the services of fire and police protection, garbage pick-up, and plowing without paying?" said Bukiewicz.

Dan Bukiewicz

Dan Bukiewicz

The judge, C. William Foust, writes that right-to-work infringes on unions' property rights because, "they have legally protectable property interest in the services they perform for members and non-members."

Rick Esenberg from the Conservative Wisconsin Institute of Law and Liberty, says non-union members are the ones whose rights are in question.


Rick Esenberg

"What they really are are forced customers. They're people who are being forced to accept and pay for something that they don't want," said Esenberg.

These dueling arguments will continue; Attorney General Brad Schimel says the state will appeal. Esenberg says this case's final destination is clear.

"Basically, what's going to happen here is that the state is going to appeal, the matter will eventually wind up before the state Supreme Court," said Esenberg.

Esenberg says he expects the Wisconsin Supreme Court to take up the case toward the end of its next term in the summer of 2017.


  • Jim

    Once again the Lefty’s prove that if they can’t win in the elections they will try to win in the court system from Dane Co. That worked so well for Act 10. Only a matter of time before this is also overturned.

  • Concerned Citizen

    Unions are legal mafias. There are absolutely no controls on what they can or can’t do. They are a mockery of our legal system. Companies that try and defend themselves must first work through the NLRB ajudication process, a process that is governed by union attorneys.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.