Virtual Phone Bank: Consider a donation to Feeding America Eastern Wisconsin
Important resources to help you navigate the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in Wisconsin
Hub for reliable, timely news about COVID-19 pandemic

“I want to know what happened:” Father of Jay Anderson frustrated DA won’t release body camera evidence

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.
Data pix.

WAUWATOSA -- The father of a man killed by police in Wauwatosa says he's frustrated that some of the information released in connection with recent police shootings in North Carolina and Oklahoma still hasn't been made public in his son's case.

Jay Anderson

Jay Anderson

Friday, September 23rd will mark the three-month anniversary of Jay Anderson's death in Wauwatosa. Anderson Sr. says it's time for at least some evidence in the case to be made public.

As the signs of autumn have started to appear in Wauwatosa's Madison Park, Jay Anderson Sr. said Thursday, September 22nd he still has questions about what happened on June 23rd -- the last day of his son's life.

"I want to know what happened before my son was shot and murdered. I want to know what happened before," said Jay Anderson Sr.

Jay Anderson Sr.

Jay Anderson Sr.

A Wauwatosa police officer shot and killed Anderson as he sat in his car in Madison Park. Police say Anderson had a gun in his possession and the officer feared for his safety.

Three months later, we still know very little about the case. Anderson Sr. says his son did own a gun and he believes police when they say Anderson had it with him in the car that night.

Wauwatosa police still have not released the officer's name. They also have declined to put out the video of the shooting, even though the Milwaukee County District Attorney's Office has said that would not interfere with their review of the case.

Madison Park

Madison Park

On Thursday, police said it's Wauwatosa Police Chief Barry Weber's calland Weber doesn't want to release evidence in "bits and pieces." A department spokesman says everything will come out at the same time.

Anderson's father says he's seen the officer's body camera video, which is about 20 seconds long.

"(My son) has his hands up, trying to say he had something in the car, a gun in the car, and the third time he moved it I guess he moved too close to the gun or I believe he was going for his phone," said Anderson Sr.Jay Anderson shot and killed by Wauwatosa police officer

Anderson Sr. said it's now time to release the officer's name and adds he would also accept the release of the body camera video.

"I wish they would do that -- but they're not," said Anderson Sr.

When the video does come out, Anderson Sr. said he hopes it doesn't lead to violent scenes similar to those we saw this week in Charlotte, North Carolina or here in Milwaukee in August, in the wake of the fatal shooting of Sylville Smith by a Milwaukee police officer.

Unrest in Milwaukee

Unrest in Milwaukee

"I want all these murders to stop. These kids, these officers killing these kids, but I don't want no city that's destroyed," said Anderson Sr.

Officials with the Milwaukee County District Attorney's Office told FOX6 News Thursday they're in the later stages of their review in the Jay Anderson case. They're waiting for the FBI to see if it can enhance the clarity of the 20-second body camera video.


  • Idiots

    So dad “believes he was going for his phone”?! Wow I wonder what part of keep your hands raised where I can see them didn’t he understand? Follow police orders and you won’t get shot. Simple stuff. Stupid ignorant thugs don’t seem to understand that. So the cop was supposed to trust a person in the park in middle of the night with an arrest record that you aren’t l reaching for your gun? That is a ludicrous expectation. Wise up dad!

    • Wise up

      The excuses are BS as to why requests aren’t followed. Pretty simple! So sick of the automatic cop to blame when majority shot are thugs with criminal records.

    • SickAndTired

      I am tired of hearing/reading “white America” This is a free County feel free to seek another Country to live in….. Beware no other country gives free hand outs like the USA that is the reason most are here. I made it out of the hood with no help from anyone why cant you?

  • Huh !

    I wish people would understand Police Officers are human !!!
    If you were that cop, what would you think … Truthfully now, WHAT WOULD YOU BE THINKING when his hand moved towards the gun ???
    Why do people think the police don’t have the right to defend themselves with what ever force is available ….
    You would, and you’re not a paid officer swore to uphold the law !!!

    • SickAndTired

      People need to look at what demographic commits the most crime and gun violence that would be the people all cops look out for. Also I don’t like to be called White, I am a European American…… Calling me white is racist!

    • Slice

      you are very correct about having a gun now, when you do have a gun, maybe you should comply with what the cop is asking and not run away or do something crazy, that’s how this all starts. Also, why are you out after midnight anyway? Change your culture and you’ll see a reduction in cop killings!

  • STuck in Modern Day Slavery

    Blacks didnt come to america freely get real I guess we need to pull out the real history books. Funny how history seems to try and be rewritten in recent times.

  • Req

    Difference is there are big white dudes with records and when they don’t follow orders and get shot it doesn’t result in rioting and looting and his momma saying he was a choir boy!!!

  • Slice

    why is it still “bad white cops” when a black cop shoots a black person? Why do you just focus on a certain subsection of killings and never say one word about blacks killing blacks, everyday, by the 100’s? Why is that?

  • Al

    Wow, some of these comments are unbelievable. After 3 months, the PD cannot provide an explanation to the family why this man was killed? Something stinks here. If it was justified, why are they being so secretive and continuing to withhold information?

  • walloffthenorthside

    It’s easy. Jay was in the park for illegal reasons, thugged out on the police and got shot. There. The facts have been released.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.