Hub for reliable, timely news about COVID-19 pandemic

Federal jury awards Milwaukee man nearly $2 million in case involving illegal strip search

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.
Data pix.

MILWAUKEE -- The City of Milwaukee is on the hook for almost $2 million. That's the result of another federal lawsuit involving an illegal body cavity search by police.

"We`re very thankful to the jury," Ron Bornstein with Bornstein Law Office S.C. said.

It's the verdict one Milwaukee man and his attorney have been waiting for.


"We believe they did a remarkably fine job," Bornstein said.

A federal jury has awarded Willie Newman close to $2 million.

"The allegations were that he was illegally strip searched and that it was done intentionally, maliciously and willfully," Bornstein said.

Newman's case began about a year ago -- but his attorney said his suffering started in April of 2010.

According to a federal complaint, Newman was approached by then-Milwaukee Police Officer Michael Vagnini and others in the parking lot of a restaurant on Milwaukee's north side.

The plaintiff claimed "Vagnini drew his firearm and ordered Newman to hold his hands up and exit his vehicle" and then proceeded to strip search him.

Police recovered "a plastic bag containing marijuana." Newman was charged with possession.

Milwaukee police

"He was embarrassed and humiliated and treated as something less than human," Bornstein said.

Four Milwaukee police officers were fired and charged as a result of illegal strip searches.

In 2013, Vagnini was convicted of felony charges.

Bornstein said this latest federal verdict comes with relief.

"It restores his dignity and it was really appreciated and the jury did what we believe was a wonderful job," Bornstein said.

Michael Vagnini

Michael Vagnini

This isn't the first time the city has had to pay up for illegal strip searches.

In December of 2015, the city reached a $5 million settlement with a group of 74 men.


  • Kari Jefferson

    If you’re going to report on a verdict, perhaps you should be accurate and mention that the plaintiff’s charge was not a simple possession of marijuana charge, you kindly omitted the possession of cocaine with intent to deliver — two charges he plead guilty to. Nor was there even an allegation of a body cavity search. Additionally, you failed to mention that Mr. Newman only filed his lawsuit after others were announced on the news and never before mentioned the alleged strip search. Great reporting, Fox 6. No wonder people are so misinformed.

  • JaneDoeSpeaks

    Milwaukee county courts have been stomping on the civil rights of all people and all races for generations. Until the local lawyers defend us all equally its all going to keep on going with the same old song.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.