“Just too high:” Hawaiian lawmaker says the price of rent should be regulated

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.


HONOLULU, Hawaii — Should the price of rent be regulated? That’s a question being raised by a Hawaiian lawmaker.

Rep. Kaneila Ing of South Maui.

“The rent is just too damn high for local residents. People are getting driven out of their communities because of the influx of mainland and international investors, so this will help curb that and give local people a chance,” Rep. Kaneila Ing of South Maui said.

Rep. Ing wants to limit the amount of rent that landlords can charge. His proposal would launch a pilot project as early as next year. It would apply to newly constructed homes as well homes more than 20 years old.

“The problem is since the 90s, the average rent went from $800 to $2,400, so we want to help slow that down and allow young people to save up to buy homes and for our kupuna (elders) on a fixed income to not end up homeless and on the streets,” Ing said.

The bill would limit landlords of homes built before 1990 to charging no more than 30 percent of the area’s median income.

New developments would still be able to set their rents at the market rate, but would not be able to increase those prices by more than three percent per year.

The measure just opened to public comments and some industry insiders are already criticizing the form of rent control.

“We have some serious concerns about it applying to new construction,” Craig Hirai of Hawaii Housing Finance and Development Corporation said.

Both the Hawaii Housing Finance and Development Corporation and the Hawaii Association of Realtors oppose the bill. Some fear it’ll stop developers from building affordable housing. Others believe it to be a counter productive housing policy.

Ing said the bill’s opponents are basing their opinions on out-dated information.

“There’s also a strong lobby arm for realtor, for developers. They have a lot of influence, but there’s no tenant associations coming out in support, but I know there are a lot of people who rent who this would really help,” Ing said.


  • bydesign001

    The lawmaker has to be a Progressive, oh it doesn’t matter if they’re a Progressive Progressive or a Progressive Republican, Progressives love regulation and the downside is that the “unintended” (or is it) consequences to regulations mean higher prices.

    We are regulated to the hilt in New York City and landlords would rather take people living on the government dole over those who have a legitimate job because if the rent does not get paid, then the city or state will cover it.

  • Metal Maniac

    I’m not going to lie, I enjoy that my apartment is rent controlled in Los Angeles. My rent can only increase by 3% a year as long as I stay there. The nice thing is there are a lot of people who have lived there for a long time so it creates a community of people. Renting by nature is transient but this kind of rewards people to build a community. Landlording is a business so if they can get more money they will (no one can blame them) but as warmer cities become more and more popular the people who grew up there are forced out. Can you imagine if you were forced to leave your hometown?

    Fiscally it make no sense what-so-ever but not everyone is a fiscal person.

Comments are closed.