Already facing criticism for how it handled the warning signs about shooter Nikolas Cruz, the Broward County Sheriff’s Office could now see a state investigation over its response to the deadly February 14 school shooting.
On Sunday, Gov. Rick Scott asked the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to “immediately investigate the law enforcement response” to the shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, according to a news release from his office.
Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel said in a statement that his department “will fully cooperate” with the probe, “as we believe in full transparency and accountability.”
Israel has been under growing pressure as state House Speaker Richard Corcoran, along with 73 other Republican state representatives, called on the governor to suspend Israel for “incompetence and neglect of duty” in a letter sent Sunday.
They said that he and his deputies failed to “intervene regarding Nikolas Jacob Cruz in the years, months, and days leading up to that shooting,” which Corcoran described as “unacceptable and unforgivable.”
“Sheriff Israel failed to maintain a culture of alertness, vigilance, and thoroughness amongst his deputies. … As a result of Sheriff Israel’s failures, students and teachers died,” the letter said.
Amid calls for his suspension, Israel, a Democrat, said Sunday, “Of course I won’t resign.”
More questions have been raised as details of law enforcement’s response before and during the shooting have emerged.
Law enforcement including the FBI and local authorities received warnings about Cruz before the attack, including one caller saying the eventual gunman could be a “school shooter in the making.”
The sheriff’s office said it received several calls related to Cruz in the past decade. Israel said investigators are looking into the handling of at least two calls that may have tipped off law enforcement about Cruz.
When questioned about red flags brought to law enforcement’s attention, Israel said, “I can only take responsibility for what I knew about. I exercised my due diligence. I’ve given amazing leadership to this agency.”
What happened during the shooting?
There have also been questions about how Broward County deputies responded during the critical moments of the shooting in Parkland, Florida.
During the shooting, the armed school resource officer assigned to the school stayed outside the building where the shooting was taking place, authorities said. Scot Peterson took cover outside the school as bullets flew for 4 minutes and “never went in,” Israel had said.
“I was disgusted. I was just demoralized with the performance of former deputy (Scot) Peterson,” Israel said.
Peterson had received active shooter training, according to a letter Israel had written in response to Florida state representative Bill Hager who wrote a letter urging the governor to remove Israel from his post for his deputies’ “unfathomable inaction” during the massacre.
Peterson resigned last week following his suspension.
Questions also have mounted over what happened during the shooting. Sources have previously said that Coral Springs police officers arrived at the site of the shooting and were surprised to find three sheriff’s deputies, in addition to Peterson, had not entered the school.
Israel said his department is also looking into reports that the deputies didn’t enter the school building during the shooting, but as of now, Peterson was the only officer that he was certain had been derelict.
“We will get to the truth, but at this point, one deputy was remiss, dereliction of duty, and he’s now no longer with this agency. And that’s Peterson,” Israel said.
He added that his department’s investigation indicates the Coral Springs officers didn’t arrive until about 4 minutes after Cruz had left the campus.
A report on what Coral Springs officers observed is expected. Sources caution that surveillance video is currently being reviewed and official accounts could ultimately differ from recollections of officers on the scene.
Return to campus
As the investigations continue, Stoneman Douglas students returned to campus Sunday for a voluntary campus orientation. Grappling with trauma, some students and parents making their first emotional return to campus wore school T-shirts that read: “MSDStrong.”
“It was really scary. I didn’t know how I was going to feel when I went in and I saw the fence around the freshman building … and all the windows were covered,” sophomore Tanzil Philip said.
The building where the shooting occurred will remain closed. Armed deputies were on campus and will also be on hand when students return to class Wednesday.
Philip said students met in the theater room, “and we just gave each other hugs.”
School officials are working with students who don’t want to return to Stoneman Douglas, arranging for them to transfer.
Superintendent Robert Runcie said officials will be accommodating and take measures like adding counselors and service dogs in classrooms.