Winter weather advisory issued for all of SE Wisconsin beginning Wednesday morning

‘Stench of evilness:’ Shorewood man sentenced to 3 years in prison in sextortion case

MILWAUKEE -- A Shorewood teenager who stalked and bullied his high school classmates online will spend the next three years in state prison.

Matthew Cullen-Williams

On his way to the defendant's chair, Matthew Cullen-Williams, 19, flashed a smile at his sentencing on Friday, Jan. 18. But to his former classmates at Shorewood High School, there is nothing to smile about.

"He made these years for them a living hell; a nightmare," said Judge Joseph Wall.

Judge Wall described how Cullen-Williams used fake social media accounts to trick his own friends into sending nude photos and videos of themselves.

Judge Joseph Wall

"This was the work of a skilled manipulator with no empathy for the damage and repercussions that his actions have caused," the judge said.

Cullen-Williams then used the images as leverage to coerce at least one of the victims into sexual intercourse -- a crime commonly known as sextortion.

"This is becoming more and more ad more prevalent," Judge Wall said.

Matthew Cullen-Williams

A FOX6 investigation in 2015 showed just how prevalent it is. After our stories, state lawmakers updated state statutes to ensure sextortion is a crime. But it is still just a Class I felony -- with a maximum sentence of a year-and-a-half in prison.

Judge Wall gave Cullen-Williams one year on each of three separate counts -- three years in all.

"What comes from all this is actually a stench of evilness," the judge said.

After serving three years of confinement in state prison, Cullen-Williams will be placed on extended supervision for another six years. He also has a three-year probation sentence that starts when everything else is complete.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.