Virtual Phone Bank: Consider a donation to Feeding America Eastern Wisconsin
Important resources to help you navigate the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in Wisconsin
Hub for reliable, timely news about COVID-19 pandemic

Amani Smith pleads not guilty to charges in death of 63-year-old Waukesha man

Amani Smith

Amani Smith

WAUKESHA — Amani Smith pleaded not guilty on Thursday, Dec. 17 in connection with the homicide of a 63-year-old Waukesha man.

Smith faces the following criminal counts:

  • First-degree intentional homicide, use of a dangerous weapon
  • Arson of a building without owner’s consent
  • Mutilating a corpse
  • Take and drive vehicle without consent

Prosecutors say Smith killed Dennis Huelse in September at his home in Waukesha — and tried to cover up the crime by setting Huelse’s house on fire before stealing Huelse’s 1969 Pontiac Firebird, which he tried to sell.

1969 Pontiac Firebird missing from Waukesha residence, scene of fatal fire

According to prosecutors, Smith left his vehicle outside Huelse’s home the morning he died and came back later to pick it up. A neighbor noticed the vehicle did not belong there and tipped off police.

Fatal house fire in Waukesha

Huelse’s remains were found after the fire inside his home on University Drive near Pendleton Place in Waukesha on Sept. 26. Prosecutors said there was a knife sticking out of his neck, and dental records had to be used in order to identify him. In addition to the missing vehicle, a laptop disappeared from the home, investigators learned. A search of Huelse’s phone records led to interviews, with two female associates of Huelse telling police Smith once dropped them off at Huelse’s home.

Waukesha police on Sept. 30 announced the Pontiac Firebird was found abandoned in an alley in Milwaukee — recovered b police after a citizen contacted authorities. Prosecutors said it was found three blocks from Smith’s home. Through cellphone records and Smith’s Facebook page, prosecutors said investigators found messages that showed Smith was trying to sell the Pontiac Firebird, with messages such as, “Are you interested in old-school cars?”

Fatal house fire in Waukesha

“At some point when the investigation was ongoing, when, perhaps, he understood he was the subject of this investigation, he went to Tennessee,” said the prosecutor.

Smith took off for a couple days in early November, prosecutors said. According to a witness, he wanted to start over. He allegedly messaged a friend, writing, “I got important (expletive) to handle so I won’t go to jail for life.”

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.