Most Wisconsin schools and daycares don’t test drinking water for lead

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

MILWAUKEE — Most schools and daycares in Wisconsin are not testing their drinking water for lead, despite the Environmental Protection Agency strongly recommending that they should be.

The FOX6 Investigators asked the biggest school districts in southeastern Wisconsin if they are testing their drinking water. Of the districts that responded, all said "no." We also sent surveys to child care centers with known lead service lines in Milwaukee. Of the 20 centers we questioned, only one replied, saying they didn't know how to test.

SchoolWater10

4-year-old Casheous Wozniak was diagnosed with lead poisoning when he was a baby. His mother, Crystal, thinks it was from paint.

These answers raise serious questions about the safety of the water your kids are drinking.

Three years ago, four-year-old Casheous was diagnosed with lead poisoning. Since then, his mother Crystal Wozniak has become sort of an expert on all things lead.

"Now that I know it is an issue, I can see it everywhere I go and it's kind of devastating," Wozniak said.

She thinks her little boy got lead poisoning from paint after he chewed on a windowsill when he was still a baby.

Lead exposure is particularly dangerous for kids under six. For young kids, even a drop of lead can cause behavioral problems, learning disorders, or lost IQ points.

In Wisconsin, Casheous is just one of thousands of kids who get lead poisoning each year.

"Lead contamination in a child under six really causes brain damage. It causes, literally, cognitive problems that last that whole child's life," explained Representative Chris Taylor (D-Madison).

SchoolWater3

State Representative Chris Taylor

Rep. Taylor says she started looking at childhood lead poisoning in Wisconsin after the crisis in Flint, Michigan.

In Flint, the city used water from the Flint River, which led to elevated blood lead levels in children.

"Thousands of kids have lead poisoning in the state of Wisconsin — about 4.5 percent of children who are tested. Flint was 4.9 percent. So we're not that far behind," Taylor said.

In Wisconsin, when a kid gets lead poisoning, local health departments try to figure out where it came from.

SchoolWater1

Chuck Warzecha

"I think local health departments are real heroes in this area," said Chuck Warzecha, deputy administrator for the Division of Public Health at the Wisconsin Department of Health Services (DHS).

If a child is diagnosed with lead poisoning, a local health department conducts an investigation to figure out how the child was exposed to lead in the first place. They go to the child's home to test toys and paint. Sometimes, they even go to the child's daycare or to their grandparents' home.

The one thing they almost never do?

"They don't test water," Taylor revealed.

"It isn't a routine part of any inspection that I know of because it hasn't been found to be the significant contributor to lead poisoning," Warzecha confirmed.

While DHS admits water is always a concern for lead poisoning, they focus most of their resources on lead paint.

SchoolWater2

Lead paint is typically the focus of lead poisoning investigations.

"That's the best use of our time and resources," Warzecha said.

So when a child gets lead poisoning, most of the time, no one is testing water in their house.

"We're not testing water right now in the state of Wisconsin -- even when we have a child who, you know, has lead poisoning," Taylor said.

Kids don't just drink water home either.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) strongly recommends schools and child care facilities test their drinking water for lead. However, in Wisconsin that is not happening because state and federal laws don't require it.

"It's unconscionable to me," Taylor said.

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) admits in a letter they wrote to the EPA in 2004 that there's no programs monitoring water in schools and child care facilities, writing:

"Wisconsin does not have a special or separate program to control lead in drinking water at schools and day care facilities."

The Wisconsin DNR confirmed to the FOX6 Investigators that is still true.

"According to current regulations, unless a school is a public water system (PWS), testing for lead and copper is voluntary," said Jennifer Sereno, spokesperson for the Wisconsin DNR. "DNR does not track voluntary testing so we don’t have specifics on what schools may or may not be testing."

Currently, only schools with a private water supply — or wells — have to test their water.

SchoolWater5

Todd Miller, director of facilities at University School of Milwaukee, explains the water testing process for their buildings.

At University School of Milwaukee in River Hills, for example, they have two wells.

"Lead and copper is a standard test the DNR requires from us," explained Todd Miller, director of facilities.

The water at University School is regularly tested and those results are publicly posted for parents to see.

"It's basically just so we know whether we passed or we failed," Miller said.

But if your child goes to a school that has city water, like many do, schools are not required to test the water coming out of the sinks or fountains. Schools used to be required to test water coolers, but not anymore.

Most child care facilities in Wisconsin don't have to test their drinking water either. It is not a requirement to be licensed unless the facility uses a well.

The Wisconsin Department of Children and Families (DCF) monitors child care facilities. Communications Director Joe Scialfa told the FOX6 Investigators that "96 percent of Wisconsin’s public water systems meet health standards for drinking water" citing a 2014 Drinking Water Report from the DNR. Scialfa went on to say in a statement to the FOX6 Investigators:

"DCF works tirelessly to ensure that licensed and certified child care providers are following state child care regulations and delivering care in a safe environment.  If a child care provider receives their water supply from a municipality, we do not require additional testing since the Wisconsin Bureau of Drinking Water and Groundwater requires municipalities to follow stringent water quality rules. DCF requires child care providers who receive their water supply from private wells to test their water supply on a regular basis."

"I never had my water tested. Ever," said Representative LaTonya Johnson (D-Milwaukee).

Rep. Johnson used to run a daycare out of her home.

SchoolWater 11

State Representative LaTonya Johnson holding lead pipes from her home.

"My pipes were filled with lead," Johnson said.

While Milwaukee has some of the cleanest water in the country, homes are old. With old homes, pipes and fixtures often have lead in them.

If clean water travels through plumbing systems that contain metal, the water that comes of the faucet is more likely to be contaminated.

It's a big concern — especially in homes built before 1986.

"Children are at a greater risk because they are smaller — especially infants because of the formula. Their water intake is significantly higher," Johnson said.

Experts say there is no safe level of lead exposure for children. However, in Wisconsin, testing water even when we know a child has lead poisoning isn't a top priority.

"We don't test the water routinely because we go to what routinely causes lead poisonings," Warzecha explained.

Paint is the prime suspect in these cases. Therefore, water has largely been ignored.

The Wisconsin DNR told the FOX6 Investigators they don't track which schools or daycares might be testing their water because testing is voluntary.

So FOX6 Investigator Meghan Dwyer tried to find who is testing their water.

Dwyer sent the survey to the 10 biggest schools districts in southeastern Wisconsin including:

  • Milwaukee Public Schools

    SchoolWater13

    Survey sent to the 10 largest schools districts in Southeastern Wisconsin and child care facilities with lead service lines.

  • Kenosha Unified School District
  • Racine Unified School District
  • School District of Waukesha
  • Sheboygan Area School District
  • West Allis-West Milwaukee School District
  • Fond du Lac School District
  • Wauwatosa School District
  • Elmbrook School District
  • West Bend School District

In addition, Dwyer sent the survey to daycares in Milwaukee with known lead service lines.

Each one was asked, "Do you test for lead in drinking water at your facilities?"

All those who responded to survey said "no."

"If we are not making sure our children have safe drinking water at schools then what are we doing?  I mean, that should be our primary concern," Johnson said.

Milwaukee Public Schools responded to the survey. MPS was the only district to tell FOX6 testing will be conducted soon at some of their buildings. They told FOX6:

"EPA requires testing to be completed by the community water system that provides the service. In this case, that is the city of Milwaukee. In light of recent issues in other communities and to further reassure the community, MPS is working closely with the City of Milwaukee Health Department to develop additional protocol."

Sheboygan Area School District responded to the survey writing:

"The Sheboygan Water Utility uses an approved phosphate treatment additive to coat lead and copper water laterals and thus reduce the possibility of lead or copper dissolving in the water. As required by EPA and DNR, the Utility routinely tests water in residences for both lead and copper content to ensure compliance with safety regulations."

The Elmbrook School District told FOX6 they test the two sites that wells, which are Pilgrim Park Middle School and Tonawanda Elmentary School. The district included results showing both schools meet the state health standards. As for their other facilities, the Elmbrook School District wrote:

"All other sites are on the City of Brookfield water and are tested by the City of Brookfield."

The Wauwatosa School District told FOX6:

"All our water testing is completed through the City of Wauwatosa and we ask that any questions pertaining to the testing of the water be directed to the Water Utility Superintendent."

The West Allis-West Milwaukee School District responded:

"The City of West Allis does the testing of water in our School District."

The Racine Unified School District had a similar response:

"The city test the water coming to our buildings."

The Sheboygan Area School District responded giving more detail about the process. They wrote:

"The Sheboygan Water Utility uses an approved phosphate treatment additive to coat lead and copper water laterals and thus reduce the possibility of lead or copper dissolving in the water. As required by EPA and DNR, the Utility routinely tests water in residences for both lead and copper content to ensure compliance with safety regulations."

Kenosha Unified School District, Fond du Lac School District, West Bend School District and the School District of Waukesha did not respond to the survey.

SchoolWater7

Survey response from House of Angels Learning Center

House of Angels Learning Center was one of the daycares that responded to the survey. In their response they said, they didn't know how to test.

Dwyer visited the facility and collected a water sample. The sample was sent to the Wisconsin State Laboratory of Hygiene at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

SchoolWater8

FOX6 Investigator Meghan Dwyer collecting a water sample at House of Angels Learning Center.

The results showed the water at House of Angels Learning Center does not have lead in it.

Wozniak thinks every school and every daycare should be testing.

"I think the water should be just as important," Wozniak said.

When her son was diagnosed with lead poisoning a few years ago, paint was the main focus of the investigation. She wondered why nobody was testing her water or asking about her pipes.

"That's one of the things that we are even kind of owed," Wozniak said.

Now that her son is starting school soon, she's the one asking the questions.

"I'm worried about his brain — about his bones," Wozniak said.

SchoolWater9

Crystal Wozniak makes sure everything in her home is lead-free after her son, Casheous, was diagnosed with lead poisoning.

She wants to be sure, no matter where he's at, he's not exposed to even more lead.

"Whether that be the fence is put up, the doors are locked or the water is safe," Wozniak said.

Others states do require schools to test water. You can read more about what certain states require here.

New Jersey Democratic Congressman Donald Payne has introduced the TEST for Lead Act (H.R. 4879). It would require any state that receives funds from the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund (DWSRF) to use those funds to test lead in water at schools in that state. Right now, there’s 31 co-sponsors – none are from Wisconsin, but Wisconsin does receive DWSRF funds.

4 comments

  • Tyler G

    Wow did fox 6 just invent a public health issue to jump on the flint water bandwagon? So they parade around a kid who ate lead paint chips and got lead poisoning, talk to public health professionals who state it’s not a main focus that lead paint is the biggest cause, offer no evidence that water is lead contaminated in Milwaukee yet push that we should be passing laws and forcing daycares and schools to test water!?!? Pretty poor journalistic effort. A much better story would be outlining how much is being wasted by schools to test water based on unfounded fear!

    • Tyler g

      Also , did Rep. Taylor really say about not test water at the schools “it’s unconscionable to me”? Really… Really you worked and lobbied for planned parent hood for over 5 years and this, this is what you find unconscionable? To funny not to mention here.

  • John Williams

    Figures don’t lie but liars figure. The sampling procedure is far more critical that the testing. Water is acidic, it will leach the lead from the pipes (assuming lead pipes are used) or the lead from the solder. You can find lead in almost any household water source unless you let the water run for a while.

    Most water pipes are copper, that’s a guarantee of copper being in your water.

    As to lead in paint any home built before lead was removed from paint will have lead it it’s paint. You can believe your child is getting the lead from chewing the painted wood or you can realize the lead has washed off from rain and scraping into the soil. It is then tracked into your home on your shoes and on to your floors which are frequented by young children.

Comments are closed.