Zollicoffer trial, Milwaukee man accused in 3 homicides | Tuesday recap
Zollicoffer trial: Witnesses describe bickering, fighting before homicides
The trial of Thomas Seville Zollicoffer, a Milwaukee man accused of killing three people in one night this summer, continued Tuesday. FOX6 Investigators also explained how the public defender shortage is impacting this case.
MILWAUKEE - The trial of Thomas Seville Zollicoffer, a Milwaukee man accused of killing three people in one night this summer, continued Tuesday.
Judge David Borowski said the jury of 14 people is now down to 12. One juror was excused due to illness, while another was excused for "shunning" jury duty and could not be tracked down.
FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX LOCAL Mobile app for iOS or Android
Two shootings, three killed
The backstory:
The Milwaukee County District Attorney's Office charged Zollicoffer, 37, with three counts of first-degree intentional homicide and four counts of possession of a firearm by a felon. He pleaded not guilty and was bound over for trial in August.
Scott Bucholz, Vanessa DeHerrera, Shamarla Hare
Prosecutors said Zollicoffer shot and killed his ex-girlfriend, 26-year-old Vanessa DeHerrera, and her friend, 29-year-old Scott Bucholz, at an apartment near 21st and Pierce on Aug. 8. Less than 30 minutes later, Zollicoffer is accused of shooting and killing 39-year-old Shamarla Hare near 39th and Townsend.
The killings prompted a days-long manhunt for Zollicoffer, who was arrested at his cousin's home near 84th and Fiebrantz.
Zollicoffer trial | Tuesday, Nov. 17
In court:
Hours of bickering, fighting, claims of infidelity and name-calling preceded the moment a man shot and killed his girlfriend and her friend at a party the man showed up to unannounced, witnesses told a jury Tuesday.
Five people recounted the harrowing moments inside an apartment at 21st and Pierce, fearing they would also be shot and killed by Thomas Seville Zollicoffer. Zollicoffer is on trial for those two killings, and a third prosecutors say he committed less than 30 minutes later.
Witnesses testified Zollicoffer, 36, had showed up to the Knitting Factory Lofts unannounced and uninvited to a party. His girlfriend, Vanessa DeHerrera, was staying at the second-floor apartment at the time with her friend and the friend’s roommate, Scotty Bucholz.
Thomas Seville Zollicoffer in court for trial on Tuesday, Nov. 17.
"Throughout the night, Thomas and Vanessa were kind of bickering. He was saying very, very vulgar things to her," said the woman, as she teared up on the witness stand. "He kept calling her a b**** and a h*," recalled one of the witnesses, who said Zollicoffer also accused DeHerrera of sleeping with Bucholz and another man – the two men had recently begun dating.
"He, at some point even pulled out his phone and was showing a sex tape. He would show his gun to her, multiple times and say, ‘you act like I won’t f****** kill you,’ she would respond, ‘she’s not scared.’"
The woman – whose identity and that of other witnesses is being shielded by a judge’s order – said she went into a bedroom when she heard gunshots, and went to see what was happening.
"Thomas, standing over Vanessa, shooting her. He shot her twice and then I ran."
People in the apartment said they were partying, but that Zollicoffer was a "dark cloud," quiet and mostly kept to himself – other than arguing with DeHerrera – before the shooting started.
"I remember I mostly watched him, since he’s the one – the danger – so he shot her and he was just staring at her," said another woman about what she saw. "(DeHerrera) was slumped down – still sitting cross-legged, but still sitting with her head down. I think Scotty either exclaimed or something, ‘Oh my gosh’ or something, and it brought Thomas’s attention to everybody else. He turned around and said, ‘Oh, so y’all want some too,’ and he began shooting across the couch."
The woman said she ran into a bedroom, when Zollicoffer saw her and begged to not be shot, before Zollicoffer moved to another part of the apartment – giving her a chance to hide and call 911.
"I’m trying to answer their questions and then I heard Vanessa passing away," said the woman, as family and friends in the gallery cried.
"She was—she was gasping and I couldn’t do anything," said the woman crying, "because I didn’t know if he was still there – or not – and if I went to try and help her or talk to her, then he would shoot me."
SIGN UP TODAY: Get daily headlines, breaking news emails from FOX6 News
Willie Staten told jurors he was outside the apartment building with friends when they heard gunshots, but couldn’t pinpoint where they were coming from. Staten said about 10 minutes after the gunshots, a sedan driven by a man pulled up to the apartment and appeared to be waiting for someone. Staten said a man came out of the apartment building and got into the waiting car.
"I didn't recognize him at all," said Staten, who acknowledged under cross the description of the man he gave police didn’t exactly match that of Zollicoffer.
Prosecutors played surveillance video from the apartment building that prosecutors will say shows Zollicoffer arriving and then running out of the apartment to the waiting car.
Others charged
Dig deeper:
The district attorney's office charged Zollicoffer's cousin, 38-year-old Elana Cole, with harboring/aiding a felon and three misdemeanors. Court records show she pleaded not guilty to all charges in October, and a deferred prosecution agreement hearing is now scheduled for December.
Prosecutors also accused Zollicoffer’s friend, 47-year-old Sengchanh Phengphonsavanh, of driving Zollicoffer to and from the crime scenes. On Nov. 16, court records show Phengphonsavanh pleaded guilty to harboring/aiding a felon as part of a plea deal in exchange for his testimony against Zollicoffer at trial.
Trial coverage
Complete coverage:
FOX6 News is in court for the Thomas Seville Zollicoffer trial.
- Nov. 16: Trial begins for Milwaukee man accused of killing 3 people in 1 night
- Aug. 28: Milwaukee homicides, 3 killed; jail privileges revoked for man accused
- Aug. 14: Milwaukee homicides; man charged, accused of killing 3 people
- Aug. 11: Milwaukee homicides, wanted suspect arrested after standoff
Editor's note: This story will be updated with additional information as the trial proceeds Tuesday.
The Source: FOX6 News is in court for the trial. Additional information in this story is from the Milwaukee Police Department, Milwaukee County District Attorney's Office and Wisconsin Circuit Court records.