View election results from the 2020 spring primary

Men accused of ripping off McDonald’s, other businesses by pretending to be from corporate

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.
Data pix.

MILWAUKEE COUNTY -- Police say two thieves stole thousands of dollars without every having to step foot into the businesses they're accused of knocking off. In this case, the victims came to the suspects.

The two Milwaukee men are accused of convincing area managers that corporate officials wanted bags of cash delivered -- and they targeted some of the most recognizable brands.

Piggly Wiggly

Piggly Wiggly

Authorities say the suspects were able to steal thousands of dollars from companies like McDonald's, George Webb, BP, Piggly Wiggly, Denny's, Dickey's Barbecue Pit, Culver's, Rocky Rococo, Family Dollar, Great Clips, and Baker's Square.

Here are the exact locations targeted:

  • Rocky Rococo; 2094 Miller Park Way
  • McDonalds; S. 76th Street
  • Piggly Wiggly; 2201 E. Rawson Avenue
  • George Webb Restaurant; 12201 W. North Avenue
  • George Webb Restaurant; 6231 S. 27th Street
  • George Webb Restaurant; 3635 S. Moorland Road
  • BP Corner Mart; 15565 W. Bluemound Road
  • Family Dollar; 139 E. Broadway
  • McDonalds; 621 Ryan Street
  • Great Clips; 6535 S 27th Street
  • Cousins Subs; 7178 S 76th Street
  • Culvers; 1650 E Main Street


Here's how the scam worked: Someone would call these businesses and say they were "Dave Black," or a similar name. They said they were from corporate and there was a problem. Mr. Black told the business that a customer had lost their wallet and when they returned, there was $1,000 missing, and they needed to return it by putting money from the register into a bag. Mr. Black would then order the business officials to jump into a car or cab -- and drive to 28th and Wells in Milwaukee.



Victims indicate the suspects were very convincing -- often saying the employee's job would be at stake if they did not comply, and that the company was trying to avoid a lawsuit.

When the victims would arrive, the man whose money was allegedly missing from his wallet was there -- ready to take the bag.

But there was no Mr. Black -- nor an angry customer in real life.

Gregory Carson and Willie Herford are accused of scamming these businesses.

Gregory Carson and Willie Herford

Gregory Carson and Willie Herford

Police say they were able to use cell phone records and surveillance video to finally catch them.

The 59 and 55-year-old men are now facing a multitude of charges:


  • Eight counts of threats to injure/accuse of crime
  • 12 counts of theft-false representation (less than $2,500)


  • Three counts of threats to injure/accuse of crime
  • Three counts of theft-false representation (less than $2,500)

Carson was taken into custody on May 19th, and made his initial appearance in court on that date. Cash bond was set at $20,000.

Carson will next be in court on June 9th for a scheduling conference.

As for Herford, he was arrested on May 18th. Cash bond was set at $2,500.

Herford has an arraignment scheduled for June 9th.


  • Mark

    dirtbags, but I have to give it to them for using their imagination and acting abilities. Props jailbirds!!!

  • Andrea

    I am the manager of a local Supercuts. About a month and a half ago I had a new employee call me at home after I left expressing how scared she was that we were all going to lose our jobs because a client had come in, left a wallet, and had money stolen out of said wallet. Everything she told me was exactly what is reported in this story. I’m more than positive these guys tried this with so many more businesses that just fortunately didn’t fall for it. So sad and pathetic.

  • Elizabeth brees

    The got me too!!! I lost my job at the mc Donalds in Menomonee falls because of this! They knew everything from managers to crew to when we were open or closed early and on what days! The detectives I was working with said I shouldn’t have lost my job I’m hoping I can work something out with HR!

  • Elizabeth brees

    If they let them out they will keep doing it they have been doing it for years!!!! I am positive the old man is who I have the money to! I’m so pissed I’m so gullible !

  • head hunter

    the people that dropped off the money are STUPID!, why would you drop money off at their house, come in to the business and pick it up, they would then be on security camera, which probably would have caught them leaving a wallet!

  • Fred Jackson

    So calling your manager or other supervisor was out of the question? That would take about 2 minutes.

    • Eizabeth

      I was using the phone and it was about midnight when I got the call I didn’t think clearly because I was doing 30 things at once as I was closing manager :/ when he started the conversation he made it about me but then after made it seem like if I could help him handle this lawsuit situation he wouldn’t fire me over the other issue! He knew about it! It was crazy…

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.