“I wasn’t trying to kill her:” Milwaukee man charged with death of woman found stuffed in tote

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

MILWAUKEE -- A 22-year-old Milwaukee man has been charged in connected to the death of Kayla Bauske. Bauske's body was found stuffed into a plastic tote and left in a bedroom inside a home on Arlington Place near Brady Street Monday night, October 24th.

Justin Sykes

Justin Sykes

22-year-old Justin Sykes has been charged with one count of first degree reckless homicide.

According to police, officers were called out to a residence on Arlington Place near Brady Street shortly before midnight for a welfare check.

Upon arrival, officers were let inside by an occupant of the residence. Once inside, officials discovered the body of a 23-year-old woman. She has been identified as Kayla Bauske.

Kayla Bauske

Kayla Bauske

Sykes was then taken into custody.

According to the criminal complaint, it was determine Bauske was strangled to death. She also suffered blunt force trauma to her head, torso and extremities.

The complaint states that after her death, Bauske suffered chemical burns to her head, neck torso and genitals.

According to the criminal complaint, it was Syke's mother who made a call to Milwaukee police stating her son's friend came to her home and told her that Justin had hired a prostitute and strangled her to death after learning she stole money from him. Syke's mother told police his friend told her Justin "was on coke and drinking."

Syke's mother told police she did not know where her son lived but believed he had moved somewhere on Brady Street three weeks ago.

Police were told Sykes worked at Steny's, located 2nd Street.

The complaint states police made contact with Sykes at Steny's, who admitted to hiring a female escort but claimed she had left his residence on Arlington Place.

According to the criminal complaint, officials went to Syke's home to do a welfare check. Upon arrival, Bauske's body was found inside a rubber storage bin inside the closet of Syke's bedroom. homicide

Officials say when interviewing Sykes, he indicated he "had made a bad decision" when he hired Bauske for sex. Sykes stated to police it was not his intention to hurt her after he discovered $300 was missing from his wallet, and Bauske was attempting to leave the apartment, he tried to stop her. Woman found dead inside residence on Milwaukee's east side

Sykes told police approximately one month ago, he had an experience with a different escort who stole his phone and when he discovered his wallet missing it "freaked" him out.

According to the criminal complaint, when Sykes attempted to stop Bauske from leaving his apartment, a physical altercation occurred. He told police she kneed him in the groin and scratched him in the eye and while "freaking out she became very loud." Sykes stated to police, "I wasn't trying to kill her or anything" and he was just trying to "get her to be quiet."

Sykes told investigators he brought her back into his bedroom and in an attempt to get her to be quiet, he admitted to strangling her attempting to have her pass out but instead she "ended up dying." Sykes stated he tried to wash her off with toilet bowl cleaner for the purpose of hiding DNA evidence. He then told police he broke her legs to get her inside the tote.

FOX6 News spoke with Syke's former boss, Jerry Steny. He says his staff is shocked at the charge, describing Sykes as a "normal kid" and a "good worker" who passed a background check before he was hired.

Sykes is due back in court next week. If convicted, he faces up to 60 years behind bars.


  • Patrick Bates

    Prostitutes in Milwaukee can do whatever they want and know most men are NOT going to report them.
    What can they do? She stole from him. $300 was probably his week paycheck and who knows what she charged for the house call. Maybe $200?

    • Laurie

      She was still a human being and didn’t deserve that. Just like you wouldn’t deserve that either. Know what you’re talking about before accusing someone of stealing money. They said that he thought she stole money. Which she didn’t.
      I know this girl and she was the sweetest, kindest person and had a family just like me and you.
      Do you think because he was on cocaine,drunk and ordered a prostitute that HE deserved to be murdered; beaten, strangled, had toilet bowl cleaner for it on top of him (on his head and genitals), brake his bones, put in a tote, in the closet and left there?
      YOU are the biggest jerk for saying what you did.
      She is someone’s daughter, granddaughter, cousin…. many many many people loved her. You would have known that if you would’ve gone to her funeral. In which they had to cremate her because of what he did to her.

      ALL people go through hard times in their lives. She was in the process of changing her life. Who are you to judge? Before YOU judge YOU aught to be perfect- no one is perfect except for God.
      You don’t even know the whole story… and it’s obvious that you can’t read.
      Jack ass!!!!

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.