Important resources to help you navigate the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in Wisconsin
Hub for reliable, timely news about COVID-19 pandemic

Prosecutors: Cheesecake Factory employee shot man in Bayshore lot during argument over woman

Jose Hernandez

GLENDALE — A charge of first-degree reckless homicide was filed Friday, Jan. 31 against Jose Hernandez, 23,  in connection with a fatal shooting that occurred at Bayshore on Sunday, Jan. 26. Daniel Colon Jr. 30, died as a result of the shooting which occurred during an argument between Hernandez, a Cheesecake Factory employee, and Colon Jr., over Colon Jr.’s girlfriend’s friendship with Hernandez, prosecutors said.

According to a criminal complaint, on that Sunday, a 911 caller indicated someone had been “gunned down” and was lying in the parking lot at Bayshore. Colon Jr. suffered three gunshot wounds and was pronounced dead at the scene.

The complaint said investigators found a bullet hole in the front passenger door of Colon Jr.’s girlfriend’s vehicle, and six Luger 9mm casings in the area where the shooting occurred.

Daniel Colon Jr. -- Bayshore shooting

Daniel Colon Jr.

A construction worker told investigators he saw a white vehicle (Colon Jr.’s girlfriend’s vehicle) parked next to a blue vehicle that belonged to Hernandez. Colon Jr. exited the white vehicle and struck Hernandez’s vehicle with an object that was later determined to be a tire iron, according to prosecutors. Hernandez then ran towards the blue vehicle, armed with a firearm, as the white vehicle reversed and headed over to the Cheesecake Factory parking lot. The construction worker said Hernandez eventually ran towards the white vehicle, and the witness heard four to five shots fired — with the shooter then running back to the blue vehicle. A license plate reader captured the vehicle’s plate as it left, and it was determined to belong to Hernandez, who was determined to be an employee at Cheesecake Factory, the complaint said.

A second witness said there was an argument between two men in the Cheesecake Factory lot — with one man raising his hands in the air, and a second man pointing a gun. He said the victim pleaded with the shooter, telling him, “Please don’t, please don’t” backing away from the armed man. As the victim began running, the man with the gun started shooting, the witness told investigators.

Colon Jr.’s girlfriend said she was working at Cheesecake Factory with Hernandez when Colon Jr. arrived and got into her vehicle. There was then an argument between the two about the woman’s friendship with Hernandez — who walked from another lot where he had parked towards Cheesecake Factory. Colon Jr. got out of the vehicle he was in, and there was then an argument between Colon Jr. and Hernandez. Prosecutors said Hernandez told Colon Jr. he wouldn’t prevent Hernandez and the woman from being friends. That’s when prosecutors said Colon Jr. got the tire iron from his girlfriend’s trunk. Colon Jr. then used the tire iron to break windows on Hernandez’s vehicle, the complaint said. She then drove back to where Colon Jr.’s vehicle was parked. The two men began arguing again, and the woman said she heard a gunshot and saw a window explode. Colon Jr. ran, and later collapsed.

30-year-old man fatally shot in US Bank parking lot near Bayshore

Police: 30-year-old man fatally shot in US Bank parking lot near Bayshore Mall

Police: 30-year-old man fatally shot in US Bank parking lot near Bayshore Mall

Police: 30-year-old man fatally shot in US Bank parking lot near Bayshore Mall

If convicted on the charge, Hernandez faces up to 60 years in prison. He is due back in court on Monday, Feb. 10 for an initial appearance.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.