Senate debate: Tammy Baldwin, Eric Hovde meet in Madison

MADISON, Wis. - Democratic U.S. Sen. Tammy Baldwin and Republican challenger Eric Hovde repeatedly accused each other of lying over the course of their closely watched Senate race during an often-testy and confrontational debate Friday.

SIGN UP TODAY: Get daily headlines, breaking news emails from FOX6 News

Here are eight takeaways from the debate, held in Madison and hosted by the Wisconsin Broadcasters Association:

Repeated allegations of lying

In their back-and-forth, each candidate accused the other of playing fast and loose with the truth, both on the campaign trail and during the debate itself.

"The one thing you’ve perfected in Washington is your ability to lie," Hovde said during an exchange about Social Security.

His comment came after Baldwin pointed out that Hovde supports returning the federal budget to 2019 levels, which she said will result in massive cuts to popular programs like Social Security.

"He supports spending, just not for you," Baldwin said.

Baldwin noted that more than a dozen independent fact-checkers found that Hovde made false statements during the campaign.

Hovde responded by alleging that "Every single one of her ads has been false." He offered no evidence to back that up.

Hovde gets personal, Baldwin tells him to mind his own business

Hovde repeatedly called on Baldwin to disclose more information about the investments and business dealings of her partner, Maria Brisbane, ranked by Forbes as one of the nation's top female wealth advisers. There is no requirement for Baldwin to release that information.

"They don’t disclose those investments and how much they’re profiting from it," Hovde said, calling it a conflict of interest for Baldwin. "That’s fundamentally wrong."

FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX6 News app for iOS or Android.

"Eric Hovde should stay out of my personal life," Baldwin shot back. "And I think I speak for most Wisconsin women that he should stay out of all of our personal lives."

If elected, Hovde would be one of the richest members of the Senate based on his campaign finance report, which showed he has assets worth between about $195 million and more than $564 million. Baldwin listed assets between $601,000 and nearly $1.3 million.

Baldwin supports national abortion law. Hovde wants states to decide

Baldwin voiced her support for passing a federal law that would make abortion legal nationwide, as it was before the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022.

"Women are dying because of the current situation," she said. "Harrowing things are happening to women in this state."

Hovde previously said he supported the overturning of Roe v. Wade, but now says he would not vote for a federal ban on abortion. Instead, he says, states should decide. That is a change of position from 2012, when Hovde last ran for Senate as someone "totally opposed" to abortion.

"I’m not for a national abortion ban," Hovde said during the debate. "I never have been."

Former President Donald Trump, who has endorsed Hovde, has suggested that he would support a federal ban.

Hovde produces utility bill to prove he doesn't live in California

Baldwin and her supporters have tried to paint Hovde as more California than Wisconsin because he owns a $7 million estate in the Pacific seaside city of Laguna Beach and owns Sunwest Bank, which operates on the West Coast.

Hovde was born and raised in Wisconsin.

"I’m supposedly a jerk from California," he said before pulling from his pocket a document that he said was a utility bill for his Madison. He challenged Baldwin to produce 10 years of utility bills to prove where she lives.

Baldwin backs Obamacare. Hovde wants changes

Baldwin voiced strong support for the the national health care law, while Hovde called for changes.

"We need to build upon the Affordable Care Act," Baldwin said.

Hovde said the law has not slowed health care cost increases, improved access or allowed people to keep their doctors.

"I’m a believer in results, and if you look at the results, every one of those promises has failed," he said.

Hovde opposes absentee ballot drop boxes

Hovde questioned the use of the drop boxes, which the Wisconsin Supreme Court banned in 2022 but then allowed again this year after the court became controlled by liberal justices.

"We have to create confidence in our voting system," Hovde said. "It is causing too much tension in our country. And let me tell you, it doesn’t help when our state Supreme Court brings back drop boxes, when those were only used for a pandemic. So why are they being brought back?"

Drop boxes have been used for years in Wisconsin, but they became more prevalent in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic.

More than 500 boxes were used in 2020, but this year the Wisconsin Elections Commission said it is aware of only 78 in use. There could be more since communities don't have to report them.

Presidential race is largely absent from the debate

There was only one passing reference to Trump and not a single mention of Democratic candidate Vice President Kamala Harris during the hourlong debate. Hovde backs Trump and has appeared at his rallies. Baldwin supports Harris and has spoken at her events in the state.

The stakes

Democrats must hold onto the Wisconsin seat if they hope to maintain their slim majority in the Senate. Democrats are defending 23 seats, while Republicans have just 11 up for grabs this election.

Republicans see an opportunity in swing-state Wisconsin, and both sides have poured money into the campaign, making it one of the five most expensive Senate races this year.

Official Statements

Tammy Baldwin campaign

After winning her US Senate debate, Tammy Baldwin for Senate is announcing her People Power Tour where she will be highlighting the grassroots enthusiasm of voters across the state. As Eric Hovde continues to hide in his office and call his friends on right wing radio, Tammy will continue showing up in places her opponent has only ever seen on a map.

In October, Tammy will host more than 90 events, visiting every media market in the state at least twice. Continuing her go everywhere approach, she will visit thirteen counties across Wisconsin in the next six days: Dane, Brown, Marathon, Milwaukee, Grant, Crawford, La Crosse, Jackson, Sauk, Waukesha, Winnebago, Wood, and Portage.

Tammy Baldwin is also announcing more than 32,000 new donors have contributed to her campaign in the 16 days since Mitch McConnell announced his $23 million onslaught of attack ads against her. This builds on Tammy Baldwin and the Democratic Party of Wisconsin’s ground game across this state featuring more than 50 offices in 43 counties, more than 16,000 volunteers, and 2.5 million voter contact attempts completed including over 750,000 door knocks.

"While Mitch McConnell and Eric Hovde have virtually unlimited funds to spend on their dark, divisive campaign, I’m proud to have the people of Wisconsin on my side," said Tammy Baldwin. "I can’t wait to start my People Power Tour, joining Wisconsinites across the state to stand up for our freedoms and ensure that working families -- not the corporations and the ultra rich -- have a voice in Washington."

Eric Hovde campaign

In case you missed it, you’re probably wondering what exactly Tammy Baldwin pitched to voters this evening. Well, if Baldwin was a saleswoman, she’d be out of business.

• Someone who will stop inflation? No, Baldwin voted for 100% of the ‘Bidenomics’ legislation directly leading to record-high inflation making life more expensive for the people of Wisconsin
• Someone who will secure the border? No, Baldwin has said we spend "too much money " securing the southern border and has repeatedly voted against border security that would prevent the flow of drugs from entering our country.
• Someone who protects children? No, Baldwin co-sponsored the Equality Act, which would force schools to allow biological men to compete in women’s sports and use women’s bathrooms.
• Someone with strong ethics? No, Baldwin is facing questions  regarding conflict-of-interest concerns stemming from her partner’s Wall Street position. Her partner, Maria Brisbane, advises "ultra high net worth" clients on investments in industries that Baldwin regulates.
• Someone who holds the country's adversaries accountable? No, Baldwin voted against the Comprehensive Iran Sanctions, Accountability and Divestment Act and supported sending $10 billion to Iran after the October 7th attacks.
• Someone who will put Wisconsinites first? No, we know Baldwin would be a rubber stamp for Kamala Harris and Tim Walz after she secured  $400,000 in taxpayer dollars that went to a Madison nonprofit that promotes gender transitions without parental notification and described the Harris-Biden administrations as "one of the greatest administrations in generations."

In reality, if you want a senator who will stop historic inflation, secure the border, protect children, has strong ethics, holds our adversaries accountable, and put Wisconsin first – then the choice is obvious.

Baldwin's pitch? More of the same failure. Eric Hovde’s pitch? Let’s make Wisconsin and America safe, prosperous, and free.

WisGOP Chair Brian Schimming

"Tonight’s debate was a resounding victory for Eric Hovde. From the moment she first arrived in Washington more than two decades ago, Tammy Baldwin has prioritized the whims and demands of special interests before the needs of Wisconsin families. After this debate, there can be no doubt that Eric Hovde is the only candidate who will stand up to lobbyists and put the people first."

Democratic Party of Wisconsin

After Eric Hovde pulled out a utility bill on the debate stage, WisDems is calling on Eric Hovde to release the utility bill for his $7 million Laguna Beach, California mansion on one of the only stretches of private beaches in California.

Reminder: Hovde has been named one of the most influential people in Orange County, California three years in a row.